The Telangana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed the State Bank of India (SBI) to pay Rs 85,000 to a 44-year-old woman after ruling that the bank failed to establish that she had authorised a disputed UPI transaction of Rs 55,000 from her account.
In an order dated November 10, the commission said the use of a UPI PIN or an authentication mechanism could not, by itself, prove that the account holder had personally approved a transaction or negligently shared her banking credentials. It said the bank must provide evidence to establish the basis for holding a customer responsible for a disputed payment.
The bench, comprising commission president Mamidi Christopher and members S Sandhya Rani and K Venkateshwarlu, directed SBI to refund the disputed Rs 55,000, pay Rs 20,000 as compensation for deficiency in banking service and provide another Rs 10,000 towards the woman’s complaint costs.
How the disputed transaction took place
The woman told the commission that Rs 55,000 was debited from her SBI account through a UPI transaction on November 3, 2022, without her knowledge, consent or authorisation.
She maintained that she had neither initiated the payment nor shared her confidential banking credentials with anyone.
After noticing the debit, she reported the suspected cyber fraud through the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal on November 6, 2022. The following day, she submitted a written complaint to the SBI branch concerned, which acknowledged receiving it.
However, she alleged that the bank did not restore the disputed amount despite being informed about the transaction. She subsequently approached the police, following which a first information report (FIR) was registered on December 31, 2024.
Alleging that SBI had failed to protect her account and address her complaint in accordance with applicable banking instructions, she approached the consumer commission. She was represented by advocate N Purnachandar.
SBI claims transaction was authenticated
SBI, represented by advocate G Krishna Reddy, denied negligence and deficiency in service. The bank argued that the transaction had been completed through its UPI facility after authentication using the customer’s UPI PIN and mobile/SIM-binding mechanism.
It maintained that the payment could not have been processed without the prescribed authentication and contended that the woman had either authorised the transaction herself or failed to keep her banking credentials confidential.
The bank also argued that the customer was responsible for safeguarding her banking details and could be held liable if she had shared them or authorised the payment. It further claimed that she had not reported the transaction within the prescribed period and denied responsibility for a loss allegedly caused by her own negligence.
The commission, however, found that the bank had not produced sufficient evidence to establish either that the woman had authorised the payment or that she had shared her confidential credentials.
It observed: “The mere fact that a UPI PIN or authentication mechanism was used does not, by itself, conclusively establish that the account holder personally authorised the transaction or that she was negligent. The bank must establish the factual basis for attributing the transaction to the customer.”
Commission finds complaint was filed within prescribed period
The bench examined the timeline of the woman’s complaints and concluded that she had reported the disputed transaction within the prescribed three-working-day period.
The transaction took place on November 3, 2022. The woman reported it through the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal on November 6 and submitted a written complaint to SBI on November 7.
Excluding Sunday, November 6, the commission treated November 7 as the third working day for its calculation. It therefore rejected the bank’s argument that the woman had failed to report the transaction within the stipulated period.
The commission also found that SBI had not established that it took effective steps to investigate the complaint, follow up with the beneficiary bank, block or recover the disputed amount, or communicate an appropriate resolution to the customer.
It held that the bank’s failure to act effectively despite receiving a timely complaint amounted to deficiency in banking service.
What RBI rules say about unauthorised transactions
The case also brings attention to the Reserve Bank of India’s framework governing customer liability in unauthorised electronic banking transactions.
Under the RBI’s customer-protection directions, customers can have zero liability in cases involving a bank’s own negligence, fraud or deficiency. In certain third-party breach cases, where neither the bank nor the customer is responsible, customers are also entitled to zero liability if they notify the bank within three working days of receiving communication about the unauthorised transaction.
The RBI framework further states that where a customer is negligent, including by sharing payment credentials, the customer bears the loss until the unauthorised transaction is reported to the bank. Any subsequent loss is to be borne by the bank.
Banks are required to take immediate steps to prevent further unauthorised transactions after receiving a complaint. The RBI’s directions also provide for a provisional credit, or shadow reversal, within 10 working days of notification in cases where the customer is entitled to zero or limited liability. Banks are required to resolve complaints and establish customer liability within a period not exceeding 90 days.
The Telangana commission’s order underscores that banks must assess the circumstances and establish evidence of customer authorisation or negligence rather than relying solely on the successful use of a UPI PIN.
SBI directed to pay Rs 85,000
Holding SBI responsible for deficiency in service, the commission directed the bank to pay the woman a total of Rs 85,000.
The amount comprises Rs 55,000 as a refund of the disputed UPI transaction, Rs 20,000 as compensation for deficiency in banking service and Rs 10,000 towards the costs of pursuing the complaint.
The ruling highlights the importance of prompt reporting and documentation in cases involving suspected digital payment fraud. Customers should preserve transaction details, cybercrime complaint acknowledgements, written complaints submitted to banks and all subsequent correspondence.
It also makes clear that authentication records alone may not be sufficient to establish a customer’s liability when a digital transaction is disputed. Banks must substantiate their claims before attributing the transaction to an account holder.
